Monday, May 18, 2009

A robot teacher?

File under dead-end educational technologies. It's cute, but there's no way that robots like this one will be an effective way to teach kids anytime soon. Check the video below, which shows the robot "Saya" reading a prerecorded text (why not show them a video?) right before the kids come up and poke and fiddle with its face.

The SFGate article claims Saya will have some ability to scold misbehaving kids and take roll call. Regardless, I can only imagine the mischief that would result if this were tried in most normal classrooms.

For the past two or three decades, there's been a regular stream of stories about prototype Japanese robots delivering the mail, bringing medicines to sick people, serving as pets, etc. Despite the breathless pronouncements from journalists about such robots becoming commonplace in a few years, Nothing ever seems to come from the experiments -- they're too expensive, the AI is limited, and certain technologies (especially visual and speech recognition) aren't ready for prime time.

On the other hand, if educators are looking for ways to engage young children, there are plenty of options, ranging from other types of technologies (video, software, online, and even 3D games) to old-school concepts such as storytelling and time capsules.

Disclosures: I am a board member of Immersive Education, which seeks to promote the use of virtual worlds in online education. I am also a personal friend of the owner of Heritage Time Capsules.

No comments:

Post a Comment

All comments will be reviewed before being published. Spam, off-topic or hateful comments will be removed.